Duel Masters Reborn

Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Duel Masters Community Forum - Duel, Discuss, Trade, Share


    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Admin
    Admin
    Admin
    Admin

    Posts : 556
    Feedback Points : +8
    Join date : 2016-11-22
    Location : Finland

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by Admin 20.04.17 17:01

    I know that generally Double substitution rule disables substitution chains so that for an example Rumble Lecter can make a Shield Force active Perfect Galaxy to leave the battle zone.

    l'd still want to ask a confirmation for a few situations. Firstly, Glais Mejicula can replace shield breaking by discarding your hand cards. Does double substitution rule prevent you from putting cards like Arque Delacerna into the battle zone instead of discarding them (with Glais Mejicula) during your opponent's turn. Also, has double substitution rule always been applied, meaning that this rule wouldn't only apply for OCG format?

    Secondly, can a duelist discard Arque Delacerna into the battle using Gigastand's ability: "When this creature would be put into your graveyard from the battle zone, you may return it to your hand instead. If you do so, discard a card from your hand". In this case, discarding could be interpreted as a separated case but it is still directly dependable on substituting Gigastand's placement to graveyard with returning it to its owner's hand and then discarding a card. Phrase "if you do" makes it more clear that you have to discard a hand card if you decide to return Gigastand to your hand instead of putting it into your graveyard.

    These questions have risen in our local DM community. Thanks in advance for any help.
    OcaVan
    OcaVan
    Black Shadow
    Black Shadow

    Posts : 166
    Feedback Points : +12
    Join date : 2017-02-02
    Location : germany

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by OcaVan 21.04.17 12:36

    You should be able to get Arque Delacerna for free with Glais Mejicula according to wording 'discard' it seems to be correct to me. The only condition is that you have to discard Delacerna in your opponnents turn. I can't say how it works with the double subsitution rule, that's always a point worth to discuss.
    I'm sure you already checked it. If not: http://duelmasters.wikia.com/wiki/Terradragon_Arque_Delacerna/Tips
    Mr-ex777
    Mr-ex777
    Master of Destruction
    Master of Destruction

    Posts : 131
    Feedback Points : None
    Join date : 2017-02-03

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by Mr-ex777 21.04.17 15:15

    No you cannot, there's a thing called the double substitution effect.
    Zach Hartigan
    Zach Hartigan
    Moderator
    Moderator

    Posts : 121
    Feedback Points : +6
    Join date : 2017-01-20
    Age : 29
    Location : Finland

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by Zach Hartigan 22.04.17 18:15

    Thats a one f******* joke! Glais Mejicula and cards with that ability have created long before "double substitution". That rule is clearly for OCG where is multiple epic chaining chances. I'd say TCG format CAN CAN CAN CAN use Delacerna, Bingole, Sanfist, Dava Torey free spam with Glais Mejicula.


    _________________
    Your Eyes are like a space. So bright and deep. I just want to drown in to em'...

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Promo114
    nitrox
    nitrox
    Moderator
    Moderator

    Posts : 42
    Feedback Points : None
    Join date : 2017-02-04
    Location : India

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by nitrox 11.11.17 5:38

    It would make sense to play TCG normally without the rules that came a long time later for the OCG, like Giant Insects also being considered Giants, and the new revision(http://duelmasters.wikia.com/wiki/March_20,_2017_Rules_revision). However, I'm not sure if the Double Substitution ruling came out officially at some point, or if it was present from the very beginning. Although most players accept that Mejicula CAN bring an Arque out.

    As for Gigastand, you are correct, the discard is not a substitution but an additional effect, and the anti-discard ability can be freely used.
    Bronze-Arm Sloth
    Bronze-Arm Sloth
    Master of Destruction
    Master of Destruction

    Posts : 136
    Feedback Points : None
    Join date : 2017-07-02
    Location : Germany

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by Bronze-Arm Sloth 12.11.17 11:52

    I second Zachs answer!
    It pretty much explains what i would have said
    Admin
    Admin
    Admin
    Admin

    Posts : 556
    Feedback Points : +8
    Join date : 2016-11-22
    Location : Finland

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by Admin 12.11.17 12:52

    nitrox wrote:As for Gigastand, you are correct, the discard is not a substitution but an additional effect, and the anti-discard ability can be freely used.
    Gigastand could be seen as a double substitution related effects since, in other words, it could be understood similarly to the following: "When this creature would be put into your graveyard from the battle zone, you may return it to your hand and discard a card from your hand instead".Now you can clearly see that discarding is a substitutive effect for the destruction of Gigastand and thus you could link Arque Delacerna's substitutive effect for discarding with that due to the Chain Rule of Double Substitution rule. I think the only reason why the ability in Gigastand is "divided" in two parts is to make it more clear in which order to proceed.

    nitrox wrote:However, I'm not sure if the Double Substitution ruling came out officially at some point, or if it was present from the very beginning. Although most players accept that Mejicula CAN bring an Arque out.
    This is the main problem. I think that Double Substitution rule has been always around in a way or another. Nevertheless, In Finland we decided to ignore Double Substitution rule entirely since it doesn't seem to bring anything game breaking in the mix. If the situation changes, we will reconsider. In OCG, we naturally apply Double Substitution rule normally.

    Sponsored content

    Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution Empty Re: Glais Mecijula, Gigastand and Double Substitution

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is 15.11.24 9:40